Resources Centre
Hotel Comparison
Tool
Compare up to three properties side-by-side across editor scores, awards, amenities, dining, and wellness — to make the most informed booking decision.
Share this comparison
Comparison Profile
Six-Dimension Analysis
| Criteria | Hotel 1Gleneagles Hotel | Hotel 2Old Course Hotel | Hotel 3The Scarlet |
|---|---|---|---|
| Editor Score | 9.5 | 9.5 | 9 |
| Location | Auchterarder, Perthshire | St. Andrews, Scotland | Mawgan Porth, Cornwall |
| Price Tier | $$$$Ultra-Luxury | $$$$Ultra-Luxury | $$$Upscale |
| Awards & Recognition | #78 World's 50 Best Hotels 2025Forbes Five-Star 2025Condé Nast Traveller Gold List 2025 | Forbes Five-StarCondé Nast Gold List | Forbes Five-StarCondé Nast Gold List |
| Highlights |
|
|
|
| Dining | 3 venues | 3 venues | 1 venue |
| Wellness | — | — | Scarlet Spa |
| Best For | Golf enthusiastsLuxury travelersOutdoor adventure seekersFood and wine connoisseursFamilies (with family-friendly accommodation options) | Golf enthusiastsLuxury travelersCouples seeking a romantic getawayWellness and spa seekersExplorers of Scottish history and culture | — |
| Book | Check Rates | Check Rates | Check Rates |